Return to PROGRAM NOTES      print this page


February 2008

Monterey Symphony Program Notes Concert Four

      February 16, 2008 (3 pm Final Rehearsal & 8 pm Concert) - Sherwood Hall, Salinas
      February 17 (3 pm) & February 18, 2008(8 pm) - Sunset Theater, Carmel
                   Marko Letonja, guest conductor
                   Tracy Dahl, soprano

 
Symphony No.3, Sinfonia sacra
          Andrzej Panufnik (1914-1991)
          Composed 1963
The Sinfonia sacra written by Andrzej Panufnik in 1963 is, as the composer himself asserted, “an expression of my religious and patriotic feelings.” Even upon an initial hearing of this dramatic work, it will be self-evident that the composer’s feelings were deep and his ability to express them superb. The work was devised as a means to commemorate Poland’s 1,000 years of statehood and Christianity, which was widely celebrated in 1966. Even the United States Postal Service issued a stamp to honor the event. The reason for all this attention had much to do with embarrassing the repressive Communist regime then in power. A popular celebration of Polish culture by an individual of Panufnik’s stature only heaped more international scorn on one of the Iron Curtain’s most repressive dictatorships.

Andrzej Panufnik, the son of a well-known violin maker, began composing at the age of nine. He studied music at the Warsaw Conservatory (1932-1936), conducting at the Vienna Academy of Music with Felix Weingartner (1937-38)and traveled to Paris and London in 1938 and 1939. With his fellow composer Witold Lutoslawski (1913-1994), Panufnik formed a piano duo, arranging many works in the common literature for piano four-hands. The duo performed during the war years at charity concerts, sanctioned and otherwise, throughout Warsaw. These skillful arrangements were also burned in the fire storm.

 After the war, Panufnik served first as the conductor of the Cracow Philharmonic Orchestra and then director of the Warsaw Philharmonic. He was widely regarded as the most important Polish conductor-composer of his time and as such received invitations to leave Communist-run Poland and travel abroad. He conducted the Berlin Philharmonic, the London Philharmonic Orchestra, and many other professional ensembles. In 1950 he was appointed vice-president of the UNESCO International Music Council.

 The Stalinist-imposed constraints on creative artists in Poland and Panufnik’s international prestige abroad contributed to his decision to remain in London, where he had traveled on official business in 1953. He was soon named the head of the City of Birmingham Symphony Orchestra and helped to build that ensemble into one of England’s finest. In 1959, he resigned from this position to commit himself entirely to composing.

 As a result of his defection, his works were not performed in Poland from 1953 to 1976. His name did not appear in dictionaries, press reviews, books or any other publications. In 1987, Panufnik published “Composing Myself”—his autobiography, which chronicles not only his artistic triumphs but his emotional distress at losing his Polish identity.

 In 1991, however, he was granted a prize from the Polish Ministry of Foreign Affairs for his contributions to Polish culture and after a 36-year absence, returned to Poland at the invitation of the Warsaw Autumn Festival. The program he presented included 11 of his pieces, three of them performed under his baton (Symphony No.10, Harmony, and Violin Concerto). In 1991, Queen Elizabeth honored him with knighthood.

 The Sinfonia sacra (Sacred Symphony) is constructed in two parts. The first, Three Visions, is subdivided into an antiphonal fanfare for four trumpets; a religious quote from the Bogurodzica—a 10th century chant, the oldest in the Polish language performed by the strings; and a battery of percussion instruments signalling Poland’s military role in protecting itself and the rest of Western Europe from invaders. The second part, Hymn, slowly builds its intensity and then climaxes into a fully stated Bogurodzica. The heraldic trumpets and percussion return to bring the work to its dramatic conclusion.

Joseph Truskot
Sinfonia from I Capuleti e i Montecchi*
Oh! Quant volte from I Capuleti e i Montecchi*

 Vincenzo Bellini (1801-1835)
In 1830, Italian composer Vincenzo Bellini composed I Capuleti e I Montecchi (The Capulets and the Montagues). Instead of calling its opening an "Overture," Bellini harkened back to an earlier time, and used the term "Sinfonia" which once indicated an all orchestral segment placed at the onset of a large Baroque choral work. Bellini’s Sinfonia is an expression of early romantic vigor. This work is rarely performed on symphonic programs despite its admirable, stand-alone qualities. Bellini’s opera is set in Verona and is a retelling of the famous Romeo and Juliet love tragedy. However, Bellini didn’t use Shakespeare’s version. Instead, he used two earlier versions (as did Shakespeare): a novella., "Giulietta e Romeo" by Matteo Bandello, and a play of the same name by Luigi Sceola. These versions themselves can be traced back to even earlier star-crossed lover stories. This opera, therefore, only has five characters and doesn’t contain Shakespeare’s embellishments—i.e., no nurse, no friar, no Mercurio.
Vincenzo Bellini was born into a musical family in Catania, Sicily in 1801. A child prodigy, he studied piano with his father. (Some stories about his youth claim he could sing complicated arias at eighteen months.) In 1819, he enrolled at the Naples Conservatory and, in 1825, received a commission from the Conservatory to compose an opera, Adelson e Salvini. Additional commissions came quickly. I pirata for Milan’s Teatro alla Scala (1827) gave this young composer international prominence. His characteristic compositional qualities included intensely passionate arias with long melodic lines sung above arpeggio notes in the harp or basses. Bellini advanced the dramatic potential of opera seria with his four masterpieces: La sonnambula (1831), Norma (1831), I puritani (1835), and this opera, I Capuleti e i Montecchi (1830).
While in Paris, Bellini met and befriended Frederic Chopin who shared his romantic approach to music, his love of writers and literature, and their ultimately fatal disease, tuberculosis. Bellini’s end was sudden. He died, outside of Paris, a few weeks short of his 35th birthday.
The Sinfonia opens with a dramatic drum roll and trumpet call, followed by melodies presented by flutes, horns, and ultimately the full orchestra. Through a series of deft transitions, the melodies of the great arias and ensemble pieces contained within the opera are presented. Prominent passages are afforded the principal flute and horn. The Sinfonia is a true curtain raiser in the grand, early 19th century style, catching the audience’s attention and providing musical snippets of what’s to come.
Juliet’s aria, "Oh! Quante volte," takes place on the balcony of her home and is the equivalent of Shakespeare’s famous balcony scene which begins, "Romeo, Romeo, Wherefore art thou, Romeo." It opens with a beautiful passage for flute and harp which, with the addition of soft strings, accompany the soprano throughout.
Oh! quante volte,                         Oh! How much time,
Oh! quante ti chiedo                    Oh! How often I beg you!
Al ciel piangendo                         The sky weeps
Con quale ardor t'attendo,            with such passion, I await you
E inganno il mio desir!                 And delude my desires!
Raggio del tuo sembiante             Your sunny looks
Parmi il brillar del giorno:              To me brighten the day
L'aura che spira intorno                The breeze that whirls around
Mi sembra un tuo respir.              Reminds me of your breath.
Although the music is wonderful, the complete opera isn’t presented as frequently as Norma or I puritani. This could be, in part, because Romeo is what’s called a "trouser role." Bellini had available to him some of the greatest mezzo-sopranos who ever lived and he assigned to them this part. Even in today’s era of fantastic special effects, there aren’t many opera divas who can be made to look like an impetuous teenage boy.
Intermezzo from Manon Lescaut
Giacomo Puccini (1858 - 1924)

Manon Lescaut was Giacomo Puccini’s first great success and there is much in it to assure its continued popularity. The story is derived from the famous romance novel by Abbé Prévost. Act I is set in a public square in Amiens in the 18th century. Des Grieux arrives at a busy tavern full of his friends and takes a seat. A carriage pulls up and Manon, her brother Lescaut, and an acquaintance, Géronte, step out. Des Grieux and Manon meet and chat. She tells him that she is being sent to a convent against her will. Her brother calls her into the tavern, but she says to him that she will return. A friend of des Grieux learns that the lecherous Géronte has plans to abduct Manon. Des Grieux and Manon meet, profess their mutual love, and elope.

Act II is set in a sumptuous apartment in Paris. Manon, having tired of her humble life with des Grieux, has set herself up with Géronte. She asks her brother Lescaut about des Grieux and is told that he is drinking and gambling heavily, trying to win enough money to woo her back. Manon is now bored with Géronte who enters with his cronies and some musicians. Manon retires to her rooms. Des Grieux enters and reproaches her for being so faithless. Being together again causes them to abandon all care and profess eternal love. Géronte discovers them and expresses his disgust. Manon laughs at him and he departs. Des Grieux urges her to come away with him immediately. Lescaut, her brother, arrives and convinces des Grieux to go away quickly. He informs Manon that Géronte has turned her in to the police who are on their way to arrest her as a degenerate. Her brother urges her to leave at once, but she stops at her vanity uncertain as to whether she can live without all her pretty things. She scoops up some of her favorite jewelry and hides. Géronte and the police enter. They find her. Géronte laughs at her as she drops the beautiful items she was clutching and is led off to prison.

Prior to Act III, the orchestra plays this quieting and exquisite Intermezzo, compiled from several soft melodies in the drama. It serves to change the character of the entire opera from the passionate love and selfishness found in Acts I and II to the punishment and remorse of Act III and IV. The scene takes place on the wharf at Le Havre. Manon is in line with other women being deported as "undesirables" to a life of servitude in Louisiana. Des Grieux and Lescaut attempt to bribe a guard but are foiled. Finally, in an impassioned aria, Des Grieux convinces the captain to take him on board as well. Act IV is a twenty-minute leibestod set on a barren plain. Des Grieux and Manon have run away from their guards. For days, they have searched desperately for food and shelter but find none. Manon is too weak to go on and dies in his arms.

Quando me'n vo from La bohème
Giacomo Puccini (1858 - 1924)
Puccini’s La boh me is a remarkable opera in many ways. First, it features ordinary people living ordinary lives—struggling artists housed in cheap rooms in Paris in the 1830's. Second, it doesn’t have much plot and holds together mostly from the strength of the characters and the impression each scene creates. Third, its melodies are among the most memorable ever composed. And lastly, its attractive qualities continue to capture new audiences. It has never left the stages of the world’s opera houses since its introduction at the Teatro Reggio in Turin on February 1, 1896 under the baton of a 29-year-old Italian conductor named Arturo Toscanini!
Act I takes place in an attic apartment lived in by Rodolfo, a poet; Marcello, a painter; Colline, a philosopher; and Schaunard, a musician. There’s no heat and little food. The landlord arrives and demands the overdue rent. They toast him with a round of drinks, encourage him to join them at the café, and depart (sans paying the rent). Rodolfo stays behind to work on an article he’s writing. He answers a knock at the door. Mimi, a neighbor, enters asking for a light for her candle. They share a beautiful moment together (and three terrific arias), eventually profess their love for each other, and go off to meet his friends in the Café Momus.
The second act takes place in the Café in the Latin Quarter of Paris. Musetta, Marcello’s former lover, arrives on the arm of Alcindoro. She sings the famous waltz, Quando me'n vo, heard at these concerts, which describes her in the most flattering terms. Rodolfo and Mimi join in the casual gathering and add their voices to the general merriment. Alcindoro is sent on an errand for Musetta. While he is away, Marcello and Musetta, former lovers, make up. All depart, leaving Alcindoro with the shoes she sent him to buy and the bill for everyone’s drinks.
Quando me’n vo soletta per la via,                                       When I walk all alone in the street
La gente sosta e mira                                                        People stop and stare at me
E la bellezza mia tutta ricerca in me                                    And look for my whole beauty
Da capo a pie'...                                                                From head to feet
Ed assaporo allor la bramosia                                            And then I taste the slight yearning
Sottil, che da gli occhi traspira                                           which transpires from their eyes
E dai palesi vezzi intender sa                                             and which is able to perceive from manifest charms
Alle occulte belt .                                                              to most hidden beauties.
Cos l'effluvio del des o tutta m'aggira,                                  So the scent of desire surrounds me,
Felice mi fa!                                                                      it makes me happy!
E tu che sai, che memori                                                   And you, who knows and remembers me,
e ti struggi                                                                        Who longs for me,
Da me tanto rifuggi?                                                          Why do you shrink from me?
So ben:                                                                            I know it very well:
le angoscie tue non le vuoi dir,                                            you don't want to express your anguish,
Ma ti senti morir!                                                               but you feel you're dying!
A gate to the city of Paris on bleak wintry day is the setting for the third act. Mimi enters shivering with cold. She finds Marcello who has given up art for sign painting. Mimi tells him she is tired of Rodolfo’s insane jealousy and his constant bickering. Musetta comes out of the tavern with Rodolfo. Mimi hides. Musetta starts arguing with Marcello. Rodolfo complains about Mimi. Mimi coughs. Rodolfo discovers her and is again smitten with love.
Act Four takes place back in the attic. Rodolfo and Marcello are back living together having broken off with their mistresses. Colline and Schaunard arrive with some food. The four start clowning around. Musetta arrives with sad news. Mimi, who is with her outside, is desperately ill. They rush out and bring Mimi in. With great care, they make her lie down on the sofa. Again the lovers are in each other’s arms and past quarrels are forgotten. The friends all want to help Mimi and each one agrees to sell a personal belonging to get money to help her. The lovers are together again. Rodolfo goes to close the curtains, thinking Mimi is asleep. The friends return to see that she has died. Heartbroken, Rodolfo cries out her name and the opera ends.                                                                                                                                                                                                        Joseph Truskot

Prelude to Act I from La traviata
Ah fors lui . . . sempre libere from La traviata
Giuseppe Verdi (1813-1901)

In 1848, Alexander Dumas, Jr. published "The Lady of the Camellias" and it caused a sensation across Europe. Its main character, Marguerite Gautier, was based on a true life person, Rose Alphonsine Plessis. She was a peasant girl from the village of Nonant west of Paris who ran away from home at the age of fifteen to escape an abusive father. She used her natural intelligence and attractive looks to gain a place in society. She was said to possess a natural dignity as well as sensuous nature, happily accepting all that was given to her and destroying no one. She eventually married the Vicomte de Perrégaux in London but soon contracted and died of tuberculosis in 1847 at the age of twenty-three.

The book was so popular, Dumas rearranged it into a stage play, which has been presented in hundreds of productions and films starring many of the world’s most prominent actresses. It was often retitled, "Camille."

Dumas’ stage play was enormously popular. Giuseppe Verdi certainly learned of it while in Paris making arrangements for his opera, I vespri Siciliani. Verdi had just completed Rigoletto and Il trovatore and sought a departure from grand historic dramas. He wrote in a letter that he sought something "simple, moving, and passionate." His great librettist Francesco Piave presented him with an idea based on "Le dame aux Camélias." The heroine was renamed Violetta Valery and La traviata was born. The opera was premiered at Teatro La Fenice in Venice only six years after Alphonsine had died.

The Prelude to Act I of La traviata, is a fine example of Verdi’s genius. It begins in hushed tones, full of pathos and acquiescence. Then, Verdi introduces a theme not heard until the final act when Violetta lies dying (Addio del passado). It is the melody that Violetta sings when she knows it’s too late for help. A remarkably uplifting counter-melody (a second melody played concurrently with the main melody) offers hope. In this elegant Prelude, Verdi presents the melody to which Violetta sings "Ah, della traviata sorridi al desio; a lei, deh, perdona; tu accoglila, o Dio!" (Ah, smile upon the woman who has strayed; forgive her, oh God. Grant she may come to thee!) This is a musical quote of the only time in the entire opera the word "traviata" appears. In so doing, Verdi provides musically, in the Prelude, the opera’s title.

Prior to La traviata, most operas dealt with mythological characters or historic personages, long dead. La traviata was set in Paris at the time of its composition. At its premiere, the singers wore costumes similar to the clothes the audience was wearing. It was a dramatic departure from the past, quickly accepted by opera goers and foreshadowing an entire movement in Italian opera called "verismo." These characters were ones you could have met on the street. Their struggles dealt with the common emotional woes many people had to face.

Violetta Valery is a courtesan, a woman kept in luxury by her admirer, the Baron Douphol. In Act I, Violetta is giving a party in her home which is a cause of great celebration. She is introduced to Alfredo Germont, who eventually admits to her that he has loved her since he first saw her. As dawn breaks and the guests depart, Violetta sings the great aria heard on this program, "Ah fors’e lui . . . sempre libre." It’s a tour de force for all sopranos.

Ah, fors'e lui che I'anima                          Ah, perhaps he is the one
solinga ne' tumulti                                   whom my soul.
godea sovente pingere                             lonely in the tumult, loved
de' suoi colori occulti!                              to imagine in in secrecy!
Lui che modesto e vigile                          Watchful though I never knew it
all’egre soglie ascese,                             he came here while I lay sick
e nuova febbre accese,                            awakening a new fever,
destandomi all'amor.                               the fever of love,
A quell'amor ch'é palpito                          of love which is the very breath
del'universo intero,                                  of the universe itself -
misterioso, altero,                                  Mysterious and noble,
popoloso deserto                                   crowded desert
croce e delizia al cor!                              both cross and ecstasy of the heart.
Follie! follie! Delirio vane e questo!            Folly! All is folly! This is mad delirium!
Povera donna, sola,                                A poor woman, alone,
abbandonata in questo                            lost in this
che appellano Parigi.                               which is known to men as Paris.
Che spero or piu?                                   What can I hope for?
Che far degg'io? Gioire,                          What should I do? Revel
di volutta ne' vortici perir.                         in the whirlpool of earthly pleasures.
Gioir, gioir!                                             Revel in joy! Ah!
Sempre libera degg'io                              Forever free, I must pass
folleggiare di gioia in gioia,                       madly from joy to joy.
vo' che scorra il viver mio                         My life's course shall be
pei sentieri del piacer.                             forever in the paths of pleasure.
Nasca il giorno, o il giorno muoia,             Whether it be dawn or dusk,
sempre lieta ne' ritrovi,                            I must always live. Ah!
a diletti sempre nuovi                              Gaily in the world's gay places,
dee volare il mio pensier.                         ever seeking newer joys.
The center section of La traviata accounts the love between Alfredo and Violetta, the intrusion of Alfredo’s father and his forcing Violetta to break off the relationship. Violetta goes back to the Baron Douphol. Alfredo challenges the Baron to a duel and wounds him. Eventually, Giorgio Germont explains all, but it is too late. Alfredo and Violetta meet again in the final act before Violetta dies. In contrast to the high emotions expressed in the death chamber, Verdi composed celebratory choruses sung by Carnival revelers out on the street. It serves to heighten the sense that, in spite of tragedy, life goes on. Remember the counter-melody of the Prelude?

At the time Verdi composed La traviata, he was living openly with the soprano Giuseppina Strepponi whom he would not marry her until 1859. The father of Verdi’s first wife (she and her two sons had all died of disease within a three-year span) and one of his earliest patrons adamantly opposed this unsanctified liaison. They were all living in the small town of Busetto. The similarity between the troubles in his own life and those of the characters in La traviata would not have been lost on such a keen observer as Giuseppe Verdi. Joseph Truskot